BarkBox vs PupBox vs RescueBox — Our Pick: Bark
Dog Box Guide
Updated for 2025 Dog subscription boxes Puppies • Adults • Power chewers

BarkBox vs PupBox vs RescueBox

We compared toys, treats, customization, rescue impact, and value. Our pick: Bark (BarkBox) for the best mix of fun themes, personalization, and overall quality.

Best overall dog box

Why we prefer Bark (BarkBox)

  • Super-fun monthly themes with high-quality toys, treats, and a chew in every box.
  • Strong personalization options (size, play style, sensitivities) so boxes fit your dog.
  • Great options for heavy chewers via the Super Chewer line.
  • Friendly customer support and a well-known “happy dog” satisfaction mindset.
Heads-up: Raising a brand-new puppy and want training content in every box? PupBox focuses on age-based guidance. Want your purchase to help shelter animals? RescueBox leans into donating food and support with each box.

At a glance

Bark (BarkBox)

Best overall

Top pick for most dog parents: strong themes, lots of toys and treats, and flexible personalization for size, play style, and sensitivities.

  • Themed monthly boxes packed with toys, treats, and a chew.
  • Great customization options, plus Super Chewer for tough dogs.
  • Strong overall value and tons of fun for most dogs.
Get BarkBox

PupBox

Best for puppies

Puppy-focused subscription with age-based toys, treats, and training guides that evolve as your dog grows.

  • Boxes tailored to your puppy’s age and development stage.
  • Training tips and guides included to help with puppyhood.
  • More narrowly focused on the puppy stage than long-term for adult dogs.
Explore PupBox

RescueBox

Best for giving back

Subscription that combines toys and treats with a mission: each box helps feed and support shelter animals in need.

  • Includes a mix of premium toys, treats, and chews.
  • Every box helps provide food for shelter pets.
  • Less individually customized than BarkBox, but strong rescue focus.
See RescueBox
What to compare Bark (BarkBox) PupBox RescueBox
Primary strength Best overall: customization + fun themes + value Puppy-focused boxes with age-based training support Charity-driven boxes that help feed shelter animals
Personalization Detailed profile (size, play style, sensitivities) and Super Chewer option for tougher dogs Boxes evolve with your puppy’s age and size over time Basic size and pet-type selection; less granular per-dog customization
Toys & treats High-quality treats and toys designed around a monthly theme Curated puppy toys, treats, chews, and accessories for early development Mix of toys, treats, and chews with rotating themes
Extras & perks Access to Super Chewer, special collabs, seasonal boxes, and add-ons Training tips, checklists, and guidance aimed at new puppy parents Rescue-oriented messaging and impact updates from partner charities
Themes & unboxing Highly creative monthly themes; very “Instagram-ready” unboxings Themes tied to puppy milestones and training stages Cute seasonal and rescue-inspired themes
Dog age range Great for most ages, from pups to adults; options for heavy chewers Best in the first 1–2 years, when training needs are highest Suitable for most dogs; also offers a cat box
Shipping & reliability Monthly deliveries with wide US availability and clear tracking Monthly US-focused shipping tied to your subscription plan Monthly subscription through GreaterGood’s platform
Customer support Responsive support; easy to adjust boxes or flag toy issues Support for subscribers and training questions via online channels Support managed through GreaterGood / RescueBox customer service
Satisfaction & policies Strong “happy dog” satisfaction attitude and flexible account tools Standard subscription management; details vary by current offer Policies handled by the retailer; check site for latest terms
Best for Dog parents who want the most fun and customizable monthly box New puppy owners who also want built-in training help Pet parents who want their subscription to support rescue work
Editorial stance: Want the most complete, customizable dog box? Choose Bark (BarkBox). Raising a young pup and need training tips? Start with PupBox. Want your subscription to maximize shelter impact? Go with RescueBox.

Pick by use-case

Best overall dog box

The strongest blend of toys, treats, themes, and personalization for most dogs and households.

Get BarkBox

Best for new puppies

PupBox is ideal if you want monthly training tips and age-appropriate goodies as your puppy grows.

See PupBox

Best for giving back

RescueBox is great if you want to spoil your pet while helping feed and support shelter animals.

See RescueBox

FAQ

What is a dog subscription box?
A dog subscription box is a monthly delivery of curated toys, treats, and other goodies for your pet. You subscribe once, then a new themed box arrives every month with items chosen for your dog.
How is BarkBox different from PupBox and RescueBox?
BarkBox focuses on fun themes, strong toy and treat selection, and lots of customization, making it the best all-rounder. PupBox is centered on puppies, with age-based boxes and training guidance. RescueBox gives a portion of proceeds to help feed and support animals in shelters, so it’s the best fit if giving back is your priority.
Is BarkBox good for puppies and heavy chewers?
BarkBox can work well for many puppies, especially if you tell them about your dog’s size and play style. For dogs that destroy toys quickly, Bark’s Super Chewer option offers tougher, more durable toys designed for power chewers.
Can I cancel or pause BarkBox, PupBox, or RescueBox?
All three brands let you manage your subscription online, including changing your plan or canceling. Exact rules about pausing, renewing, and refunds depend on your billing term and current promotions, so it’s always best to double-check the latest policy on each brand’s website before you sign up.

© Dog Box Guide — Clear, honest dog subscription box comparisons.

We may earn a commission when you purchase through our links.